plutonianshores

Thank you for writing/drawing for me! I’m plutonianshores on AO3, and I’ve got a few previous letters on this journal if you’d like more info about what I like in fics or art. I've requested both fic and art for all fandoms.

My letters have a tendency to get long, but as long as you avoid my DNWs and my requested victims have a bad time, I'll have a good time. Feel free to include your favorite kinks! As long as it's not listed in my DNWs, I will love it (seriously, I've only met about 3 kinks I didn't love)

All requests are for fic and art. I've tried to choose at least a few tags and tag prompts that go well with each, although my ship-based prompts tend more towards fic setup.

I've requested graphic violence and rape/noncon warnings for all. You can go as wild as you want with the violence as long as you don't violate my DNWs. Death of the rapist is always fine, although I’d prefer no permanent death of the victim during the course of the work for fandoms where I didn’t select a "Major Character Death" warning. (Works referencing canonical character deaths are always fine, regardless of warning selection. Temporary character death followed by resurrection is also always fine.)

I'm cool with any sex acts, including anal, oral, vaginal, frottage, handjobs/fingering, rimming, intercrural, fisting, sounding, and victim forced to penetrate the rapist. Feel free to throw in more than one rapist for origfic and ships with "any character/antagonist" as the perpetrator. Rapist, victim, or outsider POV are all good! Any background/consensual ships in addition to the noncon are also fine, aside from the few ships I’ve DNWed in their respective canon requests.

DNWs
General Likes
Les Mis
Society of Gentlemen
Think of England
Critical Role
The Penumbra Podcast
The Magnus Archives
The Alienist
The Magicians
The Umbrella Academy
The Terror

DNWs

Body horror DNWs:
- Pregnancy, parasites, any kind of baby or creature inside someone, or any kind of body expansion/growth/inflation/bulging
- Quadruple amputation (1-2 amputations are fine!) or permanent damage/change to genitals including prolapse, mutilation, sex change, or blade fucking (Exception: temporary injuries healed by magic within the story)

Stylistic DNWs:
- Second person POV
- The spelling "cum" ("come" is fine!)
- Modern/mundane/no-magic Aus

Character DNWs:
- Sex involving prepubescent characters, or emphasizing that underage victims are physically undeveloped
- Trans victims
- Sex pollen/heat as the rapist (I'd prefer if a character induces the state in one or both victims)

ART-SPECIFIC LIKES (feel free to use in fic as well!)

Rapist coming on the victim, especially facials

Bruises and blood (especially bleeding from the nose or mouth)

Weapons used during rape; gunplay; knifeplay; fucked with the hilt of a weapon

Crying

"Face down ass up" position

Red marks from being slapped or hit

Bondage

Scarification, branding, cutting, marking the victim with words or symbols

Rapists dressing victims up in sexy or revealing clothing, lingerie, etc

GENERAL LIKES

Forced arousal/orgasm, the rapist making the victim get off on the rape (note: I'm totally down for painful and/or humiliating rapes with no victim arousal too!)

The words cock and cunt (although all other genitalia words are also good, if you have different preferences!)

Rapist complimenting or praising the victim, especially telling them what a good whore/slut/[insert slur here] they are or calling them a good boy/girl

(For m/m and f/f) Internalized homophobia on the part of the victim, feeling like they deserve the rape because they've had or wanted to have consensual gay sex (especially in historical fandoms/settings)

Branding/cutting/scarring, especially the rapist carving insults, slurs, or marks of ownership into the victim

Gunplay; oral, anal, or vaginal rape with a gun, pistol whipping, and my bulletproof kink: the rapist pulls the trigger on an unloaded gun, and for a moment the victim thinks they're about to die

Size kink, the victim being overwhelmed by the size of the rapist's dick or dildo or the object they're being raped with

Breathplay/asphyxia/choking

Rapists dosing their victims with sex pollen/aphrodisiacs to make them get off on the rape/orgasm multiple times

Rapist pissing on the victim, or making the victim piss themselves (other types of watersports are good too, although drinking urine does nothing for me unless the victim is drinking it straight from the rapist)

Sounding/urethral insertion

(Sexual or nonsexual) torture, injuries, bruises, broken bones and dislocated joints, blood

Someone forced to watch their lover being raped, or better yet, watching someone they have un-acted-on feelings for be raped

Fuck or die, especially if both parties have feelings for each other that they've never dared act on, and especially if they both think the other's feelings are strictly platonic

Forced incest; forced to watch a relative's rape

Bestiality - feel free to have the rapist/s use any animal you like to fuck the victim/s. I'm not big on humans penetrating animals, however.

Victim killing the rapist mid-rape or post-rape

This is even more optional than the rest of my likes, but I do love my rape fic with a side of recovery. I also love rape aftermath, with the victim cleaning up and either talking about what happened or avoiding all of their friends (especially fun when the friends witnessed the rape)

Les Misérables - Victor Hugo

Requested Warnings

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Major Character Death

Ships

Javert noncons Enjolras - Possibly a post-barricades AU where Javert directs his impulses into Punishing The Rebels instead of killing himself, taking on Enjolras as his personal project for entirely selfless reasons (and definitely not because Enjolras is pretty and Javert wants to see him suffer)

National Guards/Soldiers/Municipal Guards make Combeferre noncon Enjolras - I’m especially into a dynamic where Combeferre has feelings for Enjolras he’s never dared act on or vice versa, and this makes the forced noncon even more torturous. Maybe the antagonists tell Combeferre that either he rapes Enjolras or they all will (and maybe they go back on their word after Combeferre is finished and gang rape Enjolras anyway). Maybe they threaten death to both of them if Combeferre doesn’t rape Enjolras, and Enjolras would rather accept death but Combeferre can’t bring himself to let Enjolras die.

National Guards/Soldiers/Municipal Guards make Grantaire noncon Enjolras - I’m especially into a dynamic where Combeferre has feelings for Enjolras he’s never dared act on, and this makes the forced noncon even more torturous. Maybe the antagonists tell Grantaire that either he rapes Enjolras or they all will (and maybe they go back on their word after Combeferre is finished and gang rape Enjolras anyway). Maybe they threaten death to both of them if Grantaire doesn’t rape Enjolras, and Enjolras would rather accept death but Grantaire can’t bring himself to let Enjolras die

National Guards/Soldiers/Municipal Guards noncon Enjolras

OMC(s) noncon Enjolras

Politicians noncon Enjolras - prompting for this and the previous two ships together, because really I just want to see Enjolras get (gang) raped. Could be politically motivated/retaliation for his political activities, or just someone thinking he has a pretty face. Would love to see him suffering stoically through the assault, determined not to let his attacker/s see him break

National Guards/Soldiers/Municipal Guards make Valjean noncon Marius - tfw you go to the barricades to rescue your daughter’s lover and end up forced to fuck him instead. You can have them know each other or not, but I think it would be especially fun if the guards/etc see Valjean focusing on Marius and single them out for punishment, possibly with Marius having to come to terms with meeting Valjean again in the context of him being Cosette’s dad and both of them trying to hide what happened from Cosette

National Guards/Soldiers/Municipal Guards noncon Marius - I am especially fond of a some-characters-live AU setup where the National Guard/etc tell Marius that if he offers himself up for their use, they’ll release his friends/compatriots (bonus points for those compatriots being disdainful of Marius for bailing them out of the consequences of rebellion, not realizing that he didn’t use his money or status but his arse to get them out of jail.) But really I just want bad things happening to Marius concurrently with the barricades or post-barricades. I’d also be very into Cosette knowing that something is wrong post-rape, but not being able to figure out just what’s happened to Marius.

Patron Minette noncons Marius Pontmercy - Maybe they catch Marius (or think they catch Marius) spying on them, or they see him hanging around Eponine and decide to teach him a lesson, or they just see him and think he looks pretty and/or fun to torment. I am especially into Montparnasse thinking Marius might possibly be more attractive than him, and deciding to ruin his pretty face

Freeforms

bound and gagged

Branding - especially with a symbol of the government for the relevant ships

Breathplay

Captivity - If you want to do a longer plot arc, I’m especially into the victim/s getting locked up and raped multiple times over the course of multiple days by the rapist/s, eventually getting used to captivity, and having to readjust to actual life when they escape/are freed. For shorter-term and art-friendly stuff, I love victims tied up/chained up/etc, environmental details of where the victim is being held, the stress of never knowing when their captor is going to show up and rape them next, and the feeling that escaping from the rape/rapist is impossible or very difficult

condescending praise - especially telling the victim how pretty/attractive they are or how they were born for sucking cock/getting fucked/etc

Forced Orgasm

Forced to Deepthroat until Unconscious

Fucked Until Unconscious

Gun Kink - especially getting fucked with a gun or getting forced to suck off a gun

Interrogation - whether about the revolution/political connections or something else

Knifeplay

Non-Con Body Worship - I am very into Enjolras or Marius being told how attractive they are during their rape

Object Insertion - I am fine with literally any object that grabs you. Getting fucked with a gun is always fun, as are bottles or riding crops or any household object. I’m just very into the humiliation aspect of getting fucked by objects.

Rape to Break Character's Will/Spirit

Raped In Front Of An Audience

restrained and raped for days

Torture

Victim is beaten/abused for their lack of arousal - especially combined with homophobia directed towards the victim, with the rapist/s saying they know the victim is gay/queer/etc, so they should be enjoying this

Victim is manhandled and passed around

Victim is Marked/Branded by Rapist - I’m especially into rapists marking their victim with their initials

Society of Gentlemen - K. J. Charles

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Ships

Lord Maltravers noncons David Cyprian - Maltravers menacing and hitting Cyprian was so good for my id, and the only thing that could make it better is Maltravers raping him as well. Perhaps he has the impression that hiring Cyprian would come along with less orthodox services, and gets his way via force or more blackmail when Cyprian doesn’t comply. Or maybe Maltravers seeks out Cyprian and rapes him post-book as revenge for his discrediting/humiliation. (Or you could combine both!)

Original Character noncons David Cyprian - Hi yes I just want some Cyprian whump. You can take any excuse for setup, whether Cyprian ends up in the clutches of a dangerous man (or woman if you’d like!) while doing business for the Ricardians or for his own ends, whether he catches someone of high status’s eye and they have their way with him through use of force or blackmail, something set before the events of the series (underage is fine), or anything else.

For both ships, I’m very into Cyprian hiding what happened from Richard (and Richard finding out anyway or Cyprian eventually having to tell him if you’re into it), and Cyprian plotting revenge against his rapist. In terms of background/consensual ships, I’ve assumed Cyprian/Richard, but I’m also open to other ships (I’m especially partial to friends-with-benefits Cyprian/Quex/Shakespeare, especially if you do something pre-canon).

Freeforms

Blackmailed / Coerced Into Sex - There is plenty of blackmailable material about Cyprian himself, but I would especially be into the rapist using threats against Richard to get Cyprian to comply

Breathplay

condescending praise - especially telling the victim how pretty/attractive they are or how they were born for sucking cock/getting fucked/etc, with the implication that he’s not good for anything else

Defiant Victim

Drugged victim - I’m very into Cyprian getting caught unawares by a drugged drink or something similar (and maybe hating himself for being caught unawares

Fisting

Forced Deepthroat/Choking on a Dick

Forced Orgasm

Forced to Deepthroat until Unconscious

Forced to Make Out with Rapist

Former Rapist Confronts Victim Who Thinks They're Safe - especially if there’s an initial encounter that happens in public/around other people, with Cyprian not wanting to explain just why he’s so panicked about seeing this person

Hair-pulling - the books make such a big deal of his hair, I’d love to see the rapist fixate on it too

Marked/Branded as Property - this could work especially well with the rapist viewing Cyprian as Richard’s property rather than equal, and erasing Richard’s claim by putting their own mark on Cyprian

Object Insertion I am fine with literally any object that grabs you. Getting fucked with a gun is always fun, as are bottles or riding crops or any household object. I’m just very into the humiliation aspect of getting fucked by objects.

Rape & Revenge - I’d love to see Cyprian plotting his revenge throughout the rape, and then putting it into action

Rape at gunpoint

Rape Depicted Through Flashbacks During Later Consensual Sex - I’m picturing a scenario with Cyprian and Richard having sex post-rape, with Cyprian not having told Richard what happens, and Cyprian finding himself reacting poorly and Richard not knowing what’s wrong but noticing that something is clearly wrong

Rapist accuses victim of enticing them - with Maltravers, telling Cyprian that everyone knows what he’s been doing with Richard and Cyprian really should have expected that anyone else looking to hire him would be expecting sexual favors; with an OC, something similar minus the hiring aspect

Using Victim's Education/Status To Degrade Them - it’s a soft spot for Cyprian in the books, and I’d love to see a rapist stomp hard on that soft spot

Victim is beaten/abused for their lack of arousal - the rapist saying that clearly Cyprian was asking for this, they know he’s into men/open to being fucked by anyone with status/etc, and therefore his lack of arousal is clearly a personal affront

Think of England – K. J. Charles
Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Ships

James Armstrong and Peter Holt noncon Daniel da Silva - Daniel getting tied up underground was good and all, but I would love to pile even more trauma on top of him by having Armstrong and Holt rape him. I would love to see them deciding to have some fun with him before they eliminate him, particularly with some homophobia thrown in

Original Character noncons Daniel da Silva

Original Character noncons Archie Curtis & Daniel da Silva

Original Character noncons Archie Curtis - spying is dangerous business, with lots of opportunities to fall into the hands of some very bad people. (It doesn’t have to be related to the spying, but that’s where my mind went first – although it could also be fun to have either or both of the characters be attacked when they aren’t even working.) You could set it pre- or post-canon, whichever you prefer. I just want bad things to happen to Archie, Daniel, or both.

Freeforms

Blackmailed / Coerced Into Sex - I am especially partial to Archie getting blackmailed into sex to protect Daniel, or vice versa. I’m sure there’s any number of things about them that could be used for blackmail, although proof of sodomy would be the obvious tack

Coerced Into Honeypot Mission(s) - I have never gotten over Daniel’s comment that Vaizey finds it useful to have a few queers on staff, and I can’t help but wonder if honeypot mission are one of those uses. For Archie, it would be especially fun to see him get outed to Vaizey, and Vaizey deciding to put his experience with men to good use

Double Penetration in One Hole

Drugged victim - any method and means of drugging is fine, although I have the image in my head of either of them taking a drink from a man they’d been sent to seduce and ending up the 1910s equivalent of roofied

Forced Orgasm

Forced to Make Out with Rapist

Forced to Watch Rape - no preference as to whether it’s Archie or Daniel being forced tow watch

Gun Kink - I am especially partial to Archie’s gun being taken and used against either him or Daniel (or both of them)

Honeypot Mission Gone Wrong - perhaps the target finds out that the man trying to seduce him is working for the government, or perhaps he’s just a garden-variety rapist and has no idea his latest victim is a spy (which could lead to a nasty surprise for him when his victim fights back much more than expected or his victim’s partner comes to the rescue)

Interrogation

Object Insertion - I am fine with literally any object that grabs you. Getting fucked with a gun is always fun, as are bottles or knife hilts or any household object. I’m just very into the humiliation aspect of getting fucked by objects.

Rape at gunpoint

Rapist accuses victim of enticing them

Rapist Toys With Victim's Body Piercings - Daniel canonically has the nipple piercing, and I would love to see a rapist (especially Armstrong and Holt) discovering it and exploring how reactive he is to it. As for Archie, if you’d like to give him piercings too, I’m very into the idea that he ended up getting a matching nipple ring with Daniel, and I would imagine that discovering this straight-laced ex-soldier has a piercing would be a novelty.

Submitting to Rape to Distract Aggressor - especially where one character knows the other is off getting help (or on his way getting ready to attack) and he just needs to hold on until then

Undercover Job Takes a Bad Turn

Undercover Role Requires Being Raped

Victim is beaten/abused for their lack of arousal - especially in a honeypot scenario, with the rapist irate that the victim was coming onto him and can’t even get it up for him

Victim Kills Rapist Mid-Rape - for Archie, I’d love to see him go berserk again on his rapist, and for Daniel, I would love to see him kill his rapist on instinct and then deal with all the fallout of killing his first man. Feel free to play fast and loose with the tag and have it be Archie killing Daniel’s rapist or vice versa, as well.

Victim Mocks Rapist(s) - I would love to see Daniel’s sardonic comments at his rapist, and while Archie might not be as fast with mockery I am sure he would try, bless him

Critical Role (Web Series)

Fandom-specific DNW: Monogamous Jester/Caleb or Mollymauk/Caleb as a background/consensual ship (these ships as part of polyships are fine!)

I’m not quite done with Campaign 1 (on ep 102 as of writing this), although I’ve looked up spoilers and intend to be done with it by the time of reveals. Please forgive any prompts that read as ‘off’ with the context of the last few episodes!

Other than my DNWs, I’m fine with any consensual ships among Vox Machina and the Mighty Nein, although I’m especially partial to Polymachina and Polynein.

I couldn’t fit the freeform in, but I would also love a victim kills rapist mid-rape fanwork, as it seems very much something any of these characters would do.

Feel free to get xeno with the nonhuman characters or nonhuman Ocs!

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Major Character Death

Rape/Non-Con

Underage – particularly for precanon Percy or Cassandra noncon

Ships

Anna Ripley noncons Percy de Rolo - any and all noncon set during the time Ripley was interrogating Percy is great – I know there’s some out there already but I always crave more. I’m particularly into her taking a scientific and analytical approach to how best to violate him so he’ll crack and tell her what she wants to know. I’d also love an AU where she gets her hands on him during the course of the campaign and rapes him.

Any noncons Vox Machina - I am very flexible here. You can include only some of Vox Machina, have some of the NPCs or guest players along for the ride, and set it during either Scanlan’s or Tary’s tenure. I just desperately want more noncon for this fandom. I’m especially partial to some members of VM having to watch other members raped, or some members forced to fuck other members (through threats of violence, use of mind control, or another method). You could make the "any" one of their canonical enemies, an OC enemy they fight together, a tentacle monster, a haunted house, really anything you’d like. Go wild!

Delilah Briarwood & Sylas Briarwood noncon Cassandra de Rolo - (yes she is nommed as Cassandra Briarwood, that’s my fault. Too many noms too quickly!) Delilah and Sylas are so delightfully sinister, and I desperately want them doing dirtybadwrong things to Cassandra while she’s under their control. I would love this equally as violent rape or as a less physically violent manipulation, especially taking into consideration the Stockholm syndrome Cassandra has going on by the time Vox Machina arrive. Maybe the Briarwoods punish her by raping her when she does something wrong, or "reward" her with a gentler rape when she’s behaving.

Delilah Briarwood & Sylas Briarwood noncon Vax'ildan - this is another ship where there’s already some delightful noncon but I want more. I am into both fully-enchanted Vax who only realizes later how wrong what they’re doing to him is, or pretending-to-be-enchanted Vax who has to go along with everything the Briarwoods say lest they find out he’s not actually under their control (and maybe Briarwoods who realize he’s playing them but are enjoying making him humiliate himself)

Any noncons the Mighty Nein - Again, I am very flexible here. You can include only some of the Mighty Nein, have some of the NPCs or guest players along for the ride, and set it during either Molly’s or Cad’s time on the team (or have both of them there!). I just desperately want more noncon for this fandom. I’m especially partial to some members of the M9 having to watch other members raped, or some members forced to fuck other members (through threats of violence, use of mind control, or another method). You could make the "any" one of their canonical enemies, an OC enemy they fight together, a tentacle monster, a haunted house, really anything you’d like. Go wild!

Original Character noncons Caleb Widogast - I am pretty much wide open to whatever you’d like to do with an original character! I could see Caleb as having done sex work post-Ikithon and pre-Mighty Nein, so a job gone bad is my first thought here. I’d also love a bad guy (or bad gal/etc, I’m fine with any gender of original character) getting the jump on the Mighty Nein and deciding they want Caleb. But really any plot or setup is good (and any gender and species for the OC).

Trent Ikithon noncons Caleb Widogast - I am very here for Ikithon using his position to manipulate Caleb into a sexual relationship, or using rape as a punishment for Caleb. I just love Caleb’s fucked up past and would love anything delving into that. Feel free to bring in Astrid and Eodwulf as either additional victims or additional perpetrators, or both. Alternatively, feel free to set something during the current timeline of the show and have Ikithon track down Caleb and the rest of the Mighty Nein.

Freeforms

Blood Kink - For the Briarwood prompts, the allure of including bloodplay is obvious, but it doesn’t need to be limited to vampire rapists. Maybe the rapist needs blood for magic, or they just like the look of their victim bleeding. Anything that bloodies up my requested victims is good!

Character Forced to Watch Other Character Getting Gang Raped

Compelled to Obey Orders - there are so many magical possibilities for enforced obedience. My very favorite flavor of this is when the victim’s thoughts are at least partially their own and they hate what they’re doing, but they can’t stop.

forced bestiality - I’m very into rapists having their victims fucked by animals for entertainment. The classic is dogs, but feel free to go for any other animal (especially D&D fantasy animals) as well! I only ask that if you choose a bigger animal, you play by porn logic and don’t cause any permanent damage to the victims.
- If you want to get really cruel for Vox Machina, you could have someone control Trinket to rape Vex and/or any other VM member.
- Carrying on the "their own pets turned against them" theme, the M9 do have the moorbounders now, and those could make for an interesting bestiality gangbang

Forced into Incest by Third Party - The obvious choice here is Vax/Vex, and I am so here for an antagonist making them fuck each other for his/her/their entertainment. But I’m also very into any possible incest combos – Percy/Cassandra and Jester/Marion come to mind. The only thing I absolutely don’t want is Luke Brenatto included in this, and I’d prefer no AUs where unrelated-in-canon characters are related.

Forced To Confess Sexual Fantasies To Desired Partner And Perform Them With Rapist - I ship pretty much any combo of Vox Machina and any combo of the Mighty Nein, so feel free to pick your favorite ship here. I’m especially into it if the victim hasn’t actually confessed their feelings for their partner, or if they’re an established couple/triad/etc but have never had sex together.

Forced to have sex for entertainment of third party

Forced to Rape Mind-Controlled/Brainwashed/Possessed/etc Person - I’m especially into the rapist casting Feeblemind on one of the party and making the rest of the party rape them, with the rape made all the worse by how little the Feebleminded victim understands what’s going on and how the others can’t explain to them what’s happening.

Forced to wear revealing clothing - I just really want to see what Exandrian lingerie looks like, and have the victim/s humiliated by being forced into sexy clothes

Fucked With Hilt Of A Weapon - I’d especially love to see any of the characters having their weapons taken from them and used against them. I didn’t request gunplay because of the general scarcity of guns in the setting, but in the case of Percy, fucked with the barrel of his gun is very much welcome as well

Offering self for rape to save another - no preference on who offers themselves to save who, I am good with any character combination

One Victim Forced to Teach The Other Victim What to Do - especially with a virgin or very inexperienced victim, and the teacher feeling incredibly sad/guilty that this will be their first experience with sex. Of the characters, I could see Tary, Jester, Keyleth, or Caduceus being the least experienced and Scanlan, Caleb, or Beau being more experienced/the teacher, but go with whatever combo you would enjoy most!

Raped by Mind-Controlled/Brainwashed/Possessed/etc Person - of Vox Machina, Grog is the most susceptible to mind control, and him as the "rapist" has the added bonus of the brutality and size of goliath rape, and how badly he would feel afterwards when he regains control of his mind. But I can easily be sold on any other member of Vox Machina as well. I don’t have a preference for the Mighty Nein, other than enjoying the larger party members being forced to rape the smaller ones (see my size difference prompt). I am in this for the horror of watching your friend fail to fight off a mind control spell and then rape you, and also for the horrible guilt that comes afterwards when the mind control wears off

Rapist changes looks to someone Victim knows/likes (magical/science/etc) - D&D mechanics offer so many opportunities! You could have the rapist be a shape-shifting creature like the Rakshasa from Campaign 1 (and if you go that route, watching Vax be raped by a Gilmore facsimile would be deliciously awful) or a spell to transform their appearance. It would be especially twisted to have the rapist turn themselves into a dead party member or family member/friend

Rapist Kills and Resurrects Victim - Gotta put those resurrection mechanics to good use! I am very into temporary death, and also very into gore, so feel free to make the death that the victim is resurrected from as gruesome as you want. I’m pretty into vivisection if you want to have the rapist get inside the victim’s guts. But really I just want anything where the victim dies mid-rape and then is thrown back to life, particularly if the rape continues through the resurrection

Size Difference - The different D&D races add a lot of opportunities for size kink. I’d love to see the larger party members forced to fuck the smaller ones, or any of the characters falling into the grasp of some larger beings. I don’t want permanent damage to the victim due to the size though, so probably no goliath-on-gnome or firbolg-on-goblin action unless you are careful about things.

Victim comforts loved one who was forced to watch

Victim forced to strip for audience

Victim Magically/etc Forced To Feel Rapist's Pleasure

Victim/s added to Rapist's Harem - I am very into a rapist who has a collection of particularly interesting people and decides that they want to add one or more of Vox Machina or the Mighty Nein to this collection. Bonus points for the rest of the group having to figure out how to rescue the kidnapped member/s.

The Penumbra Podcast

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Ships

any noncons Juno Steel - I just want more Juno whump in the world. I will take almost any antagonist (would prefer it not be Peter or Rita unless they’re being mind-controlled into it). Maybe the Thea-controlled Mick Mercury ends up raping Juno on the Thea’s orders, maybe one of Ramses’ robots rapes Juno, maybe he crosses the path of a very bad person during an investigation, just hurt him and I will be thrilled! (You’re welcome to use any of the specific Juno noncon in the tagset, I just wasn’t confident in my ability to prompt for all the ships)

Swamp tentacle monster noncons Sir Mark - I love whoever nommed the swamp tentacle monsters, this is such a quality ship. Sir Mark has spent a lot of time traipsing through the swap, and I’m sure there are all sorts of dangerous creatures lurking there. I would especially love if a monster grabs Mark and restrains Talfryn to make him watch (or gets Talfryn in on the action), but am totally down with a solo attack on Mark

Swamp tentacle monster noncons Damien and Arum - I would love to see Damien and Arum ambushed at any point in the canon or post-canon, but it would be especially fun if it’s while they’re still figuring out their feelings and so here they are watching their enemy-turned-maybe-ally in an incredibly vulnerable position, and fighting back entirely inappropriate arousal. But post-canon and post-get-together would also be very fun! Feel free to take your pick of genitalia and anatomy for Arum, I am totally down for xeno. I would also love, if you’re down for it, Rilla restrained and forced to watch (or the tentacles having at Rilla too)

any noncons Sir Mark - any Sir Mark whump is very welcome. Maybe he’s attacked by knights during his time trying for knighthood, maybe he runs into a dangerous monster or a dangerous human while questing. I just want bad things to happen to him, possibly with Talfryn and/or Rilla comforting him and patching him up afterwards

Freeforms

Bondage

Defiant Victim

Double Penetration in One Hole

forced drowning - this would work especially well for the swamp monster ships, with the monster holding the character/s in question underwater until just before they’re about to die and then doing it again once they recover, but I’m very into this however you want to make it happen (natural water, bathtubs, etc)

Forced Orgasm

Forced to Deepthroat until Unconscious

Interrogation - maybe someone wants information about Juno’s investigation or the business of the Second Citadel. I’m very into rape as a tool of torture in an interrogation

Misuse of Weaponry/Tools - my first thought is laser guns in Juno’s case, swords in Mark, Damien, and Arum’s case. I just really want some gunplay and/or swordplay with the rapist/s taking the victim’s weapon and using it against them! But you are also welcome to pick other tools

Rapist Aroused By Victim Fighting Back

Rapist Doses Victim with Sex Pollen - the Penumbra Podcast seems especially ripe for weaponized sex pollen, with nefarious science in Juno’s world and weird plants in the Second Citadel’s world

Ruining the Victim’s Clothes

Sex Pollen

Tentacle Rape - you could go for a tentacle creature as the sole rapist, a tentacle creature weaponized by a human (or monster) rapist, robotic tentacles, or anything else! I especially love the overwhelming nature of tentacles penetrating every possible orifice and groping every possible body part at once

Unwilling Arousal

Vibrator Bound or Fixed against Victim's Genitals - so few of my fandoms could feasibly have vibrators, so I had to request this for TPP. I love the overstimulation aspect of this, and the victim getting overwhelmed with sensation and begging the rapist to take it off. For the Second Citadel, I could see a magic-fueled vibrator, or an invention of Rilla’s that somehow the rapist gets their hands on (or maybe she gifted it to Damien, Arum, or Mark, and the rapist took it off of them)

Victim Mouths off at Rapist(s) and Makes it Worse for Themselves - I can totally see all of my requested characters mouthing off at their rapist/s even when that’s not the best move, and would love to see the fallout from that

The Magnus Archives

My absolute favorite entity is The Slaughter, but you are welcome to use any entity for ships where it’s ambiguous.

Statement-style fics are great but not required, and I haven’t been squicked by anything that’s happened in canon so far so go wild with the worms, meat, etc! You are always welcome to bring in more antagonists to make any ship a gangbang. For the Nikola ships, I don’t find people actually being flayed particularly sexy, but threats of flaying are great.

Canon-typical parasite content is fine for this fandom, so feel free to disregard that aspect of my DNWs if you want to include, say, worms.

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Major Character Death

Rape/Non-Con

Underage

Ships

Any noncons Gertrude Robinson & Gerard Keay - I didn’t have enough ship slots to request "any makes Gerard Keay noncon Gertrude Robinson", but that is also fine, as is Gertrude forced to noncon Gerry or just someone or something nonconning both of them. I love every little bit we’ve seen of these two working together, and would love to see Entity-associated beings or just plain mortal bad guys noncon them. (I’m especially into Gerry having mommy issues that affect how he views his relationship with Gertrude). The "anything" here could be any monster or Entity, any Entity-affiliated humans, just regular mundane humans, or a ritual that requires rape.

Anything makes Trevor Herbert noncon Julia Montauk - I love the relationship between these two in the few episodes we see them, and I ship them hardcore. I would love to see the angst and betrayal resulting from a forced-to-rape scenario, and I’m especially into Trevor and Julia having an established relationship with some heavy kink and how that contrasts with the rape. The "anything" here could be any monster or Entity, any Entity-affiliated humans, just regular mundane humans (and it would be especially fun to see Trevor and Julia’s reaction to being overpowered by just normal non-magical people), or a ritual that requires rape.

Danny Stoker noncons Tim Stoker - I love the sibling incest and the "this isn’t really Danny anymore" aspect of this ship. I’m especially into Danny insisting Tim has always been harboring less-than-platonic feelings for him (and maybe Tim has been, which is making this all the worse). A Tim-lives AU where Danny survives the foiled ritual and keeps Tim around as a prisoner might be fun

Nikola Orsinov & Danny Stoker noncon Tim Stoker - Everything for the Danny noncons Tim prompts still goes, but adding in my favorite living mannequin! Nikola is just so delightfully threatening and creepy, and I’d love to see her have her way with Tim. You can have Nikola use a strap-on (or maybe a dildo or something she’s made part of her mannequin form), her fist, or anything else to fuck Tim, or just use Danny for all the physical fucking.

Nikola Orsinov noncons Gertrude Robinson - I am so here for anything about Gertrude falling into the clutches of the things she’s investigating and getting raped as a result, and I would love to see Nikola having her way with Gertrude. Possibly Nikola stroking and admiring Gertrude’s skin, talking about how she might take it for her own. You can have Nikola use a strap-on (or maybe a dildo or something she’s made part of her mannequin form), her fist, or anything else to fuck Gertrude.

Nikola Orsinov noncons Jonathan Sims & Georgie Barker - Nikola kidnapping Jon was so good to my id, and I would love a variant where she takes Georgie as well. Either Jon or Georgie forced to rape the other is great, as is Nikola just raping both of them. I am fascinated by Georgie’s lack of fear and how that would interact with being kidnapped and raped by a supernatural being. As with Gertrude, creepy exploration of skin and threats of skinning is very welcome. You can have Nikola use a strap-on (or maybe a dildo or something she’s made part of her mannequin form), her fist, or anything else to fuck Jon and Georgie, or just make Jon and Georgie do things to each other.

Nikola Orsinov noncons Melanie King - I have no idea when this would happen but it would be so hot! Maybe Nikola shows up to give a statement and Melanie is the only one present to take it, and things escalate from menacing to rape. Or maybe Melanie gets kidnapped instead of Jon. I am very into Slaughter!Melanie raging against Nikola even though she’s unable to stop her. You can have Nikola use a strap-on (or maybe a dildo or something she’s made part of her mannequin form), her fist, or anything else to fuck Melanie.

Elias Bouchard noncons Gerard Keay - could be during Gerry’s time with Gertrude, with Elias looking for information about Gertrude’s plans or just menacing Gerry, or post-death (maybe an AU where Elias gets his hands on the book page before Jon burns it and finds a way to metaphysically rape Gerry)

Elias Bouchard noncons Gertrude Robinson - perhaps Elias trying to get information out of Gertrude about her Ritual-foiling plans, or just Elias bringing his Archivist to heel. Maybe Elias raping her immediately pre-murder. I would love to see Gertrude acting deeply unimpressed with Elias’s threats and violence, at least at first.

Elias Bouchard noncons Martin Blackwood & Tim Stoker, Elias Bouchard noncons Tim Stoker - I am so into Elias taking advantage of the Archival assistants. Using his mind-control powers to reveal their most shameful kinks is always good. Maybe there’s some Beholding requirement that he rape his employees to cement his hold on them

Jared Hopworth noncons Jonathan Sims - their interaction pre-coffin made me desperately want Jared demanding sex as an additional payment for helping Jon. Feel free to lean into weird body horror with Jared, and him messing around with Jon’s bones. I also love the crack headcanon that Jared has taken some animal bacula and given himself a veritable bouquet of dicks, possibly with fun animal anatomy like knots

The Lukas Family noncons Martin Blackwood - I’m very into Martin having to be gangbanged by all the Lukases for Reasons Relating To His Commitment To The Lonely, possibly at a swanky party where he is set up like a centerpiece to be used by any and all of the attendees. I’m also very into Martin telling himself he has to endure this to get intel on Peter and the Lukases (especially if he is thinking about Jon during the rape, if you are into Jon/Martin or one-sided Martin→Jon pining)

Magnus Institute Donors noncon Jonathan Sims, Magnus Institute Donors noncon Martin Blackwood, Magnus Institute Donors noncon Tim Stoker - I don’t have a clear idea for the justification behind this, but I am so in love with a setup where the Archivist or Archival assistants are offered up for public use at a party for Institute donors, possibly with an array of (magic?) sex toys and implements laid out for use as well. The donors could be normal human OCs or disciples of other Entities (maybe this is an alliance-forging thing on Elias’s part). Feel free to combine these with more than one of the characters getting gangbanged or used at the same time, or add in more of the Archival assistants

Mary Keay noncons Gerard Keay - Mary was already so horrible to Gerry, why not make it even worse? I’d prefer Gerry be a teenager in this, although underage is totally fine as long as he’s not prepubescent. Sex/rape could be required for a ritual, or it could just be Mary raping her son (possibly using rape to punish him)

Michael noncons Gerard Keay - bring on the weird non-Euclidean sex for this! My initial thought was that what remains of the original human Michael attacks Gerry out of jealousy for Gertrude’s interest in him, but I am down for any premise. I just love weird body-horrorific beings raping people, and Gerry is one of my favorite targets for angst. He or it pronouns are both fine for Michael

Not Sasha noncons Melanie King - So with Melanie as the only one who recognizes that Not-Sasha is in fact not Sasha, I’d love to see noncon playing with that, with Not-Sasha making advances on Melanie and threatening her into playing along and pretending she doesn’t know anything is up with Not-Sasha. I’d especially love to see Melanie having to pretend they’re in a normal romantic relationship in front of their coworkers. This would be especially fun with past Sasha/Melanie

The Slaughter noncons Melanie King - feel free to work out the logistics of this however you want, but my first thought is that Melanie gets gangbanged by people under the influence of the Slaughter, or by war ghosts that she comes across, or by Grifter’s Bone, or by some other manifestation of the Slaughter. Maybe the Slaughter sends a mob after her to punish her for breaking her tie with it, or maybe this happens during or after the bullet.

Freeforms

Body Horror - pretty much anything that’s been covered in the podcast is good, but I am especially fond of bone removal, removal or replacement of limbs, Spiral style weird anatomy, generally mucking about with people’s internal organs, and affiliation with an Entity changing you somehow

Defiant Victim

Deliberately induced flashbacks - For Elias ships, he has a direct line to people’s worst memories; for other ships, feel free to go with however you want the rapist to know about their victim’s traumas/triggers/etc

Double Penetration in One Hole

Double Penetration in Two Holes

Fucked Until Unconscious

Fucking Machines - I would love to see any of my requested victims strapped into a fucking machine and left for hours, possibly with the rapist/s walking away and leaving them so there’s not even anyone for them to beg to turn the machine off

Gun Kink - especially getting fucked with a gun or being forced to blow/suck off the barrel

Knifeplay - especially cutting symbols, words, etc into someone

Mind reader takes advantage of shameful kinks - Elias is the obvious choice here, but you are welcome to give any other characters mind-reading powers as well, whether or not it’s supported by canon

Non-Human Genitalia - I already mentioned my love of Jared with animal dicks, and I’m also totally down for weird Spiral genitals, Nikola giving herself a wide range of implements, alliance to an Entity making things real weird down there, or anything else!

Object Insertion - weapons, magical artifacts, generic household objects, anything goes!

Raping someone to heal/resurrect them - Of all of my fandoms, TMA seems the most likely to have rituals that require rape. I am totally down for going full necrophilia if you take the "resurrection" route, and I am very into the victim having no knowledge of the ritual and thinking this is just a ‘normal’ rape (or waking up post-resurrection and having no idea what happened and why they’re being raped)

Rapist Kills and Resurrects Victim - I have no idea how to justify this in the context of TMA lore, but this is one of my bulletproof kinks and it seems at least vaguely plausible for this fandom. Feel free to play fast and loose with worldbuilding and just resurrect people with little or no explanation

Resurrecting Cock - can also be a resurrecting strap-on if your chosen rapist doesn’t have a dick of their own

Returning to life while resurrecting-cock holders are performing the cerimonial rape

Ritual or Spell Requires Rape

Victim is manhandled and passed around

Victim is Unable/Not Allowed to Die Despite Fatal Injuries

The Alienist (TV)

I really do mean any antagonist for the relevant ships- it could be Connor or another cop, the killer, one of the criminals, a post-canon killer they're trying to track down, or anyone else you'd like. There can be multiple antagonists as well; I'm always down for a gang rape. You’re also welcome to include combinations of John, Laszlo, and Sara being raped, and any combination of them being forced to fuck each other.

I’ve read the novel, so feel free to include details from that if you’d like (but strictly TV-canon is also, of course, great!)

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Underage

Ships

Any Antagonist noncons John Moore - John seems to get put in many compromising situations in canon, and I'd love to see any of them expanded on or a new one added. The obvious choice is fic or art set after he was drugged at Paresis Hall - I'm especially into the drugged sex and the blackmail material that's being gathered, and I was kind of sad that canon dropped the thread after that scene. I'd also love a rape stemming from the scene where he encounters Connor in the alleyway, or pretty much anything involving John suffering.

Any Antagonist noncons Laszlo Kreizler - I love the parts of the show where Laszlo lost his composure, and would love to see more of that. The antagonist taunting him about his arm would be good. I'd be very into him ending up cornered and raped by a criminal he was investigating, or raped by the cops as a deterrent from his work in canon. You're welcome to add childhood sexual abuse to his backstory if that's a headcanon that interests you, and/or you could have the actions of the rapist/s bring up memories of his father's physical abuse.

Any Antagonist noncons Sara Howard - Connor's rape threats towards Sara were intriguing, and I'd be interested in seeing a take on the cops raping her to "show her her place". Or she could ask the wrong person the wrong questions during the investigation and end up being raped, or a post-canon criminal (especially a female criminal) has their way with her. I'd be very into the antagonist raping her orally or anally and telling her how kind they're being in not taking her verginity (or in the case of anal rape, that they’re being kind in not risking impregnating her). I'd love to see her determined not to let the attack get to her, because she's so aware of what showing weakness will mean for her career

John Beecham noncons Stevie Taggert - I was perhaps too into Stevie acting as bait, and I’d love to see what happens if Beecham gets his hands on him. I’d prefer Stevie to make it out alive, but be as rough on him as you want up to that point. I would love to see him feeling betrayed that Laszlo told him they’d protect him and then let him get captured anyway, and/or someone bursting in to rescue him mid-rape. I can’t recall if it’s mentioned in the TV show but in the book he has a history of sexual abuse and it would be interesting to see that factored into this scenario, especially with Stevie having finally adjusted to being safe from assault now that he’s living with Laszlo and then getting thrown into Beecham’s path.

Freeforms

Breathplay

Bruises

Captivity - If you want to do a longer plot arc, I’m especially into the victim/s getting locked up and raped multiple times over the course of multiple days by the rapist/s, eventually getting used to captivity, and having to readjust to actual life when they escape/are freed. For shorter-term and art-friendly stuff, I love victims tied up/chained up/etc, environmental details of where the victim is being held, the stress of never knowing when their captor is going to show up and rape them next, and the feeling that escaping from the rape/rapist is impossible or very difficult.

Drugged victim - Something in the style of John getting drugged at Paresis Hall is my first thought, but any drugs that result in the victim/s being incapacitated or out of it are great

Forced Deepthroat/Choking on a Dick

Forced Orgasm

Gun Kink - especially being fucked with a gun or being forced to suck on the barrel of a gun

Non-Con Body Worship - I am very into the rapist calling the victim attractive, talking about how gorgeous [insert body part here] is, and lavishing attention on various body parts

Object Insertion - I am fine with literally any object that grabs you. Getting fucked with a gun is always fun, as are bottles or any household object. I’m just very into the humiliation aspect of getting fucked by objects.

Rape Brings Back Repressed Memories of Past Rape or Sexual Abuse - feel free to play fast and loose with the "repressed" aspect. These can be legit repressed memories or just memories the victim has tried very hard not to think about since they happened. For specifics, I am cool with anything that you have in mind, but my initial thoughts were John’s rape at Paresis Hall, sexual abuse as well as the physical abuse in Laszlo’s childhood, sexual abuse pre-Laszlo for Stevie, and either CSA or rape as an adult for Sara

Rapist Praises Victim - especially praise along the lines of how good they are at this and how they’re made to be fucked, etc

Undercover Job Takes a Bad Turn - for the non-Stevie ships, I would love to see any of the characters investigating a serial killer (you can make up a new case for them to be working) and ending up in the grasp of either that serial killer or other bad people. Undercover at a gay club/etc would be especially fun for Laszlo or John.

Victim Kills Rapist Mid-Rape

Victim Raped in Front of Loved One(s) – this can be shippy loved ones, or gen colleagues/friends

The Magicians (TV)

I’ve been watching this season and toying with Monster-possessed Eliot noncons Quentin prompts and fic plots, and then the season finale came along and kind of blew up the fandom and the characters. So, feel free to ignore Quentin’s death!

Freeforms

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Ships

The Monster possessing Eliot Waugh noncons Quentin Coldwater - I loved the general vibe of the Monster’s interactions with the rest of the characters, and how it was so easy for him to pivot from almost friendly to incredibly dangerous. I especially loved the fact that he was wearing Eliot’s body for all of these interactions. The whole season I was picturing the Monster deciding he wants to have sex with Quentin, and Q having to play along so he doesn’t end up killed. You could go established Quentin/Eliot pre-Monster-possession or not for this, I would enjoy either.

Freeforms

Breathplay

Character(s) Wanted It But Not Like This - I’m very into Q pining for Eliot but not having worked up the nerve to make a move, and now he’s kindasorta getting everything he wanted with Eliot coming onto him, but unfortunately it’s possessed!Eliot

Crying - especially if the Monster asks why Quentin is crying and Quentin has to make something up to hide the fact that he’s upset

Forced to Cuddle with Rapist

Forced to Make Out with Rapist

Monster Aggressor Has No Understanding of Concept of Rape - the Monster definitely doesn’t have a grasp on humanity, and while I would also enjoy him being overtly threatening, it would be fun to see him assuming that of course Quentin wants to have sex with him (since he wanted to have sex with Eliot) and Quentin having to go along with it and not disabuse him of that

Non-Con Body Worship - I’d especially love the Monster being fascinated and excited by human bodies, and pointing out the bits of Quentin that he likes better than Eliot

Pretending to Enjoy It

Rape Depicted Through Flashbacks During Later Consensual Sex - maybe post-de-possession Quentin/Eliot where Quentin didn’t tell Eliot all of what the Monster did, but finds himself having flashbacks during sex

Rapist doesn’t understand why victim is upset afterwards

Rapist Is “Nice” So Long As The Victim Behaves

Rapist Makes Effort To Arouse Victim

Unwilling Arousal

Victim Forced to Sleep Next to Rapist

Victim Trying to Pretend They're Having Sex Consensually

The Umbrella Academy (TV)

I’m totally here for fic set during the childhoods of the characters rather than adulthood (and intended it for a lot of the ships) but I’d prefer you keep the Hargreeves siblings the age they are in the show flashbacks or older (and at least keep them not prepubescent).

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Rape/Non-Con

Underage

Ships

Ben Hargreeves' Tentacles noncon Any Hargreeves Sibling - Ben seems to hate his powers so much from what little we see of them in the show, and I’d love to make the eldritch tentacles even worse for him by making them rape people without his say-so, as he watches horrified and unable to stop them. Maybe one of his siblings pisses him off and he intends to just break out the tentacles a little bit to scare them off, but the tentacles grapple them and rape them; maybe Ben has a nightmare and wakes up to find his tentacles buried deep in the ass or pussy of one of his siblings; maybe the tentacles just grab one of his siblings with no precursor.

Reginald Hargreeves makes Grace Hargreeves noncon Vanya Hargreeves - Maybe Reginald orders a spanking that progresses to digital rape, maybe he catches Vanya flirting with someone or kissing someone (one of her siblings, a neighborhood kid/teen that she’s snuck out to see, or anyone else) and decides that rape is an appropriate punishment, maybe he’s just perving on his kid, maybe Vanya has stopped being as afraid of and willing to obey Grace as she was when Grace was first introduced and Reginald decides to remedy that by showing Vanya just what Grace can do to her. For Vanya, I am particularly into her inferiority complex about being the only sibling without powers, and Reginald playing on that (or if you go for Reginald sexually abusing her, Vanya taking a twisted sort of pride in being useful to him in at least one way).

Reginald Hargreeves makes Grace Hargreeves noncon Diego Hargreeves - Maybe Reginald orders a spanking that progresses to digital rape, maybe he catches Diego flirting with someone or kissing someone (one of his siblings, a neighborhood kid/teen that he’s snuck out to see, or anyone else) and decides that rape is an appropriate punishment, maybe he’s just perving on his kid, maybe he thinks Diego and Grace are too close and decides to drive a wedge between them. I am especially into Diego feeling betrayed that Grace is following Reginald’s orders rather than disobeying Reginald to protect him.

Ghost of a Rapist makes Klaus Hargreeves noncon Diego Hargreeves - I would especially love to see the ghost possess Klaus, although I know that possession isn’t really supported by canon. I’m very into Diego not fighting back as much as he could because he worries about hurting Klaus, and Ben watching (fic from Ben’s POV could be very fun, although I’m totally down for any POV)

Freeforms

Begging - especially begging for the rape to stop and feeling very ashamed at doing so instead of remaining stoic

Bruises

condescending praise - especially telling the victim how pretty/attractive they are or how they were born for sucking cock/getting fucked/etc

Digital penetration of victim

Held Down

Object Insertion - I am fine with literally any object that grabs you. Getting fucked with a gun is always fun, as are bottles or knife hilts or any household object. I’m just very into the humiliation aspect of getting fucked by objects

Ruining the Victim’s Clothes

Spanking

Unwilling Arousal

The Terror (TV)

I haven’t read the book, and from what I’ve heard I prefer the Hickey characterization in the show but would welcome any other book details that don’t conflict too badly with show canon/characterization. Feel free to go all out with gore, gross medical details, etc with fic and art for this fandom!

Warnings Requested

Graphic Depictions Of Violence

Major Character Death

Rape/Non-Con

Ships

Cornelius Hickey noncons Harry D.S. Goodsir - I am imagining something set during the mutiny, when Hickey has Goodsir held captive. Maybe an attempt to break Goodsir’s pride (what little is left) or to convince him to cooperate. Watching Goodsir’s hope and faith in humanity slowly die over the course of the season was one of the best parts of the show, and I’d love to see a rape just absolutely crush what little of that remains by the last few episodes

Mutineers noncon Harry D.S. Goodsir - My Hickey noncons Goodsir stuff is relevant here. This could be organized by Hickey or just the mutineers independently ganging up on Goodsir. I’d love to see them taking out their anger about the expedition and the starvation/illness/etc on Goodsir, or getting ramped up into increasing brutality just out of a desire to make someone suffer

Cornelius Hickey noncons Captain Francis Crozier - this is another one I picture happening during the mutiny, since that’s when Hickey would have the most access to and control over Crozier, but feel free to set whenever. I’m very into Hickey punishing Crozier for the flogging and all of the slights and upping the ante with extra violence (maybe some stabbing and references to cannibalism)

Lt. John Irving noncons Cornelius Hickey and William Gibson - I would love to see a darker take on Irving discovering Hickey and Gibson, with Irving telling them he’ll report them for sodomy if they don’t let him use them, and justifying it to himself as punishing them. I could see Hickey being resigned to the rape and Gibson somewhat less so, but am totally down for other reactions. I’d love to see Irving having a ton of internalized homophobia that he channels into the rape, and throwing lots of homophobic dirty talk at Hickey and Gibson.

Cornelius Hickey and William Gibson noncon Lt. John Irving - In an alternate take on the above, Hickey decides that to dissuade Irving from reporting him and Gibson, he’ll seduce Irving, and when Irving proves less than amenable to seduction, Hickey uses force. I am down for Gibson as an equal partner in this, or Gibson talked into it by Hickey but very uncomfortable with the whole thing. Would love an Irving with a deeply repressed interest in men, feeling very guilty about any scrap of physical enjoyment he gets from the rape.

Captain Francis Crozier noncons Cornelius Hickey - maybe instead of or in addition to the flogging, Crozier decides to punish Hickey personally for the mutiny attempt, or maybe a drunk and mean Crozier gets sick of Hickey’s attempts at ingratiating himself and decides to see just how far Hickey’s desire to be useful to the captain goes. I’d love to see Hickey trying to figure out how he can use this to his advantage/turn this into something he can use as a coping mechanism.

Captain Francis Crozier makes crewmen noncon Cornelius Hickey - my initial thought is that instead of or in addition to the flogging, Crozier offers up Hickey for public use by the crew. I’d love to see people’s reactions to this, who is totally onboard for gang-raping someone insubordinate and who is deeply uncomfortable with it. Goodsir still treating Hickey for post-punishment injuries as he did in Punished as a Boy would be especially fantastic.

Freeforms

condescending praise - especially praising the victim’s performance with the implication that sex is all they’re good for

Cock & Ball Torture

Face Slapping

Face-Fucking

Forced Orgasm

Marked/Branded as Property - this could be marked as public property/property of the Queen (especially in the Crozier and crew noncon Hickey) or property of the individual rapist

Public Humiliation Punishment for Disobedience

Raped Multiple Times

Rapist accuses victim of enticing them

Rapist can’t get/maintain erection/aroused - especially in works set later in the series when everyone is suffering from lead poisoning, scurvy, malnutrition, etc, or in Crozier’s case, some effects of his drinking going on

Rapist pisses inside victim after coming

Rapist prematurely ejaculates

Rapist(s) Treat Victim Like Property - especially in the case of expecting the victim to drop everything whenever the rapist wants sex, and sharing the victim around like he’s a piece of property