Chocolate Box 2021

[plutonianshores]

You are welcome to include any of the major Archive warnings, i.e. rape, graphic violence, character death (canonical or noncanonical), and/or underage, in your gift, as well as any rating from G to E. Additional background ships and combining my requested ships into poly ships are very welcome. And feel free to include any of your favorite kinks! Barring my DNWs, I am into literally everything, my biggest turnon is reading fic or seeing art with the creator’s fave kinks included. I also have no preference for top/bottom or dom/sub choices in any ships if you’re writing/drawing porn.

(Apologies for formatting issues, I'll fix them up soon)

Go To: DNWs | General Likes | Art Likes | Smut Likes | Fandoms

DNWs:

• Pregnancy (some exceptions listed for canonical pregnancies in relevant fandoms)


• Oviposition


• Explicit sex/porn with prepubescent characters – you don’t need to specify age in the text, but I don’t kink on descriptions/artistic depictions of undeveloped or developing characters and would prefer they are all vaguely teenage or above for any porny fic/art. Backstory or offscreen CSA or young characters in sexual situations is totally fine!


• Permanent damage to or removal of genitals (genital injuries that are later healed is fine!)


• Trans characters having PIV sex


• Stuffing, feederism


• Safewords used outside of rape roleplay/consensual non-consent or other scenarios where a character’s "no" doesn’t actually mean "no"

General Likes:

• Hurt/comfort & hurt/no comfort & whump


• Comes Back Wrong


• Trauma and/or recovery


• Casefic and/or monster-of-the-week plots in relevant fandoms


• Internalized homophobia


• Truth serum or other magical/technologically influenced confessions of love or lust


• Accidental Baby/Child Acquisition or similar kidfic, especially characters having absolutely no idea what to do with kids if that seems IC for them


• Soulbonds – I’m more into the "proximity or magical ritual or other events causes soulbonds to form" style rather than the "fated soulmates" style, and I love soulbonds that cause the members to share emotions or thoughts or injuries or pain

Art Likes:

• I love all art styles and mediums!


• Limited color palettes


• Blood, bruises, and other injuries (maybe ship members patching each other up!)


• Ship members wearing each other’s clothes


• Dressing up fancy, clothing porn


• Casual physical contact

Smut Likes:

• My Nonconathon letter has many of my noncon likes if you are interested!


• Any sex acts (vaginal, anal, oral, frottage, handjobs, intercrural, fisting…) are good!


• My favorite words for genitalia are cock and cunt, but I don’t have any I DISlike, so use whatever you’d like in written smut


• Watersports – I am especially into pissing on or in someone, or desperation. I am not as into the sensation/taste of urine divorced from humiliation, marking, or desperation contexts, but it’s not a turn-off in any scenario


• Facials or coming on someone’s body


• BDSM, especially undernegotiated BDSM in consensual setups


• Gunplay and weaponsplay in general


• Breathplay/asphyxiation/choking


• Roleplay, especially consensual non-consent/rape roleplay

Fandoms

It (Movies – Muschietti

Fandom-specific DNWs: Feel free to set fics during It Chapter 1, as long as you don’t emphasize the physical age and development of the characters. For art, please don’t use the younger set of Losers Club actors as reference for illustrations.

General Prompts

• I want all the fic/art about the aftermath of either or both encounters with Pennywise!


• I am so into social media-style fic where the world discovers that all these famous people from incredibly different professions are somehow friends


• It-related horror is always welcome, as is rape recovery (It-perpetrated or not)


• I’m down for everyone-lives, just-Eddie-lives, or keeping all the canon deaths!
  

Ships

• Ben Hanscom & Beverly Marsh & Bill Denbrough & Mike Hanlon & Richie Tozier (IT Muschietti)
  
  • This is the surviving Losers. I’d also be down for all of the Losers or the canonically-surviving Losers & Eddie if you want!
  
  
  • I just want codependent Losers living together after the events of the movie, so much
  
  
  • Social media fic with them all tweeting at each other...
  
  
  • Working through the aftermath of Pennywise together, not necessarily healthily
  
  
  • Giant post-canon Losers road trip
    
  
  


• Ben Hanscom/Beverly Marsh/Bill Denbrough/Eddie Kaspbrak/Mike Hanlon/Richie Tozier/Stanley Uris (IT), Ben Hanscom/Beverly Marsh/Bill Denbrough/Mike Hanlon/Richie Tozier (IT Muschietti)
  
  
  • This is the surviving Losers and all the Losers respectively. I’d also be down for a canonically-surviving Losers & Eddie if you want
  
  
  • Feel free to grab any of my platonic Losers prompts too!
  
  
  • I so want a gangbang as adults that is Necessary for defeating Pennywise. I received a lovely Bill-centric gangbang last exchange, but feel free to pick him again! Mike being the bangee would also be great, although I’d enjoy any of the male Losers (my preference is against Beverly since that’s the way book canon went, but honestly if you want to write a Bev-centric gangbang I’ll probably enjoy it)
  
  
  • They all move close together after the movie, and it ends up just being a rotating door of who’s sleeping in who’s bed in any given night
  
  
  • The media trying to figure out who Richie or Bill or maybe Bev is dating, or what their relationship is to all of these men/that woman they keep being seen with
    
  
  


• Ben Hanscom/Beverly Marsh/Mike Hanlon (IT – Movies)
  
  • I was very intrigued when I saw this ship in the tagset, and honestly I just want more shippy Mike action
  
  
  • Boat and/or road trip to show Mike more of the country now that he’s not stuck in Derry anymore!
  
  
  • Ben and/or Mike’s Big Bisexual Awakening
  
  
• Bill Denbrough/Mike Hanlon (IT – Movies)
  
  • I would love to see Mike getting used to the freedom of not living in Derry, with Bill by his side
  
  
  • Bill and Mike take a road trip so Mike gets to actually see places that aren’t Derry
  
  
  • AU where it was Bill who stayed in Derry
  
  
  • Post-movie angst fic about trauma or any mental health issues you want to give either of them
    
  • I kind of want Bill and Mike fucking while Bill is still vaguely under the influence of whatever Mike drugged him with. Or drugged sex later on in a less fraught situation
    
  
  


• Mike Hanlon & Original Internet Friends (It Muschietti)
  
  • I just really want to see Mike socializing on the internet since there’s not too many people he could actually talk to in Derry. Original Internet Rivals or Enemies also very welcome!
  
  
  • Mike has a reputation on r/unresolvedmysteries or another unsolved mysteries forum as “That Weirdo Who Blames Supernatural Creatures For All The Derry Disappearances”
  
  
  • Stealth crossover with the canon/s of your choice, with Mike maybe joining a support forum for People Who Survived Horror Movies or finding other horror protagonists on conspiracy boards
  
  
  • Mike following the other Losers online, and possibly pseudonymously or anonymously commenting on book reviews/architectural websites/comedy shows/fashion boards/etc
  
  


• Pennywise/The Loser's Club (IT – Movies)
  
  • Any Pennywise-driven dubcon/noncon is great! Feel free to pick any Loser to focus on or have a full Losers noncon orgy or anything in between
  
  

Critical Role

Fandom-specific DNWs - Polynein where only Nott isn’t involved in the ship; modern/mundane AUs

Go wild with sexuality headcanons! I can’t really see Beau or Veth as ace, but otherwise I have no strong feelings on anything. Cross-orientation noncon/fuck-or-die (e.g. Beau/men, Tary/women, Cad/anyone) is very welcome.

I’m completely caught up on both campaigns, and I watch the new episodes on Fridays, so no worries about spoilers! Feel free to incorporate canon deaths (even where it means killing off one part of a ship), or do an everyone-lives AU.

Canonical pregnancies are fine to mention, but I don’t want fic focused on pregnancy-related physical events (e.g. morning sickness, sore backs or feet), and I don’t want to see pregnant characters in art.

General Prompts

• I am so into resurrection ceremonies as set up in canon, and/or the aftermath of being resurrected (whether the physical side or the mental repercussions of dying)


• This is an especially great fandom for sex pollen or accidental love potion/enchantments, and I’m down for anywhere on the consensual-to-noncon scale you want to put your sex pollen


• Post-battle moments where one or all ship members are roughed up, bruised, and/or bleeding
  

Ships

• Poly!Machina (Critical Role)
  
  • Feel free to pick any era of Vox Machina, and/or include guest players or NPCs if you’d like!
  
  
  • You don’t need to include everyone equally in your fic or art, I know it’s a huge cast. I definitely welcome giant orgies/polycules/etc, but I’m just as happy with the spotlight on a smaller subset of the group with the implication that everyone is involved with each other or that there’s a ton of intermingled poly relationships present.
    
  
  
  • I would love to see how the group ends up in a relationship, whether there’s a dramatic realization one day (maybe someone doses them with truth serum or casts a truth spell and everyone can’t stop confessing their love for everyone else!) or just a gradual slide into more and more of a romantic and/or sexual group dynamic
    
  
  
  • I’d love post-battle recovery/healing/etc
    
  
  
  • Orgies are always incredibly welcome, especially orgies involving magic used for sexy purposes. Gangbangs are also great, with any character as the focus!
    
  
  
  • For Polymachina with Taryon, I’d especially love to see it with an established relationsip between the established team members, and how Taryon ends up involved in it (I’m especially into Taryon taking that joking comment from around when he first joined about owing the team sexual favors seriously, and the rest of the team setting him straight but also inviting him to join. Or maybe there wasn’t established poly before, but Taryon unwittingly gives them the idea).
    
  
  


• Caleb Widogast/Nott | Veth Brenatto (Critical Role)
  
  • I really love Caleb and Veth’s friendship and I just think it would be neat if they kissed and/or fucked
  
  
  • Feel free to ignore Yeza, go with implied poly, or go full-on angsty infidelity
  
  
  • Something set pre-canon would be very fun, possibly set during prison
  
  
  • Mommy kink! I just want Caleb calling Veth Mama but sexually (especially if he slips up during sex and accidentally calls her it, and then they are both surprisingly into it)
  
  
  • Caleb teaching Veth magic!
  
  



• Caleb Widogast/Nott | Veth Brenatto/Yeza Brenatto (Critical Role)
  
• • I am so in love with Nott and Caleb’s friendship in the show, and once we met Yeza the three of them really clicked as a ship for me. I’m down for something set during canon, or a post-canon/future-set work (with Nott either still a goblin or back to her halfling form).
    
  
  
  • I’d love a dynamic with the three of them all feeling like they’ll ruin their friendship if they make a move on what they’re feeling (I could see Caleb especially feeling like he doesn’t deserve to be a part of Yeza and Nott’s relationship).
    
  
  
  • My kingdom for fic/art where Yeza has a massive kink for interspecies sex!
    
  
  
  • I would love to see something post-canon exploring what happens after they finish the plotline of this campaign, especially given the tension we’re seeing now between Nott’s love of adventuring and her previous life with Yeza and Luc.
    
  
  
  • After Nott’s reveal in canon that she had a thing for Caleb when they first met, I would love to see Nott and Yeza gushing to each other about how attractive they find Caleb until one or both of them finally makes a move (or maybe it’s Caleb who makes the first move?)
  
  



• Poly!Nein (Critical Role)
  
  • Any era of the Mighty Nein is great, including guest players or NPCs is also great. Feel free to include Cad on a platonic level, or tbh him hanging out during an orgy like “glad you all are having fun” and occasionally lending a hand/grabbing people snacks or drinks/whatever you like would be very fun
  
  
  • You don’t need to include everyone equally in your fic or art, I know it’s a huge cast. I definitely welcome giant orgies/polycules/etc, but I’m just as happy with the spotlight on a smaller subset of the group with the implication that everyone is involved with each other or that there’s a ton of intermingled poly relationships present. I do ask that if you write group sex, you please include Nott in it (I love her and want her to Fuck)
    
  
  
  • I would love to see how the group ends up in a relationship, whether there’s a dramatic realization one day (maybe someone doses them with truth serum or casts a truth spell and everyone can’t stop confessing their love for everyone else!) or just a gradual slide into more and more of a romantic and/or sexual group dynamic
    
  
  
  • I’d love post-battle recovery/healing/etc
    
  
  
  • Orgies are always incredibly welcome, especially orgies involving magic used for sexy purposes. Gangbangs are also great, with any character as the focus!
    
  
  


• Poly!Nein/Yeza Brenatto (Critical Role)
  
  • I so want Yeza to end up in the middle of a giant Polynein relationship, in whatever way you’d like
  
  
  
  • I am especially partial to Nott hesitantly explaining the group dynamics to him after some of the Nein get a little too touchy-feely in front of him late one night, with Nott reassuring him that of course she stays out of orgies and she’ll let them know not to pester him, and Yeza responding "Okay but can we join the orgies though?"
    
  
  
  • With Yeza’s general nerdy attitude I could see him being really into observing the cultural and anatomical differences among the M9, especially given that his and Nott’s village seemed fairly isolated. I am definitely down for this in a sexy way, but it doesn’t have to be sexual if you prefer!
    
  
  

UnDeadwood

Fandom-specific DNW: Modern/mundane AUs

Feel free to include any of the rest of the cast, or just focus on Arabella and Miriam! Everyone-lives AUs are great, as are keeping canonical character deaths intact.

Ships

• Arabella Whitlock/Miriam Landisman (Undeadwood)
  
  • I would love more delving into the magic and worldbuilding of the series, and maybe something looking at how the mechanical aspects of the game (the Bartender? The cards?) would look in a purely fictional work rather than an actual-play video
  
  
  • A "we survived" moment at the end of the series
  
  
  • Arabella and Miriam teaming up to continue fighting monsters post-canon!
  
  
  • Whump or hurt-comfort (recovering from a gunshot wound? Magic backfiring?)
  
  
  • Gunplay! Western canons are perfect for this kink, and both of these women look super hot with guns
    
  
  

The Alienist (TV)

Ships

• Bitsy Sussman/Sara Howard (Alienist TV)
  
  • I was so excited that Sara got to interact with more women this season! I just want her and Bitsy to be a crime-investigating team who also kiss and/or fuck.
  
  
  • Late nights at the office together
  
  
  • Comforting each other in the aftermath of Season 2
  
  
  • How did they first meet?
  
  
  • Working on cases together
  
  


• John Schuyler Moore/Laszlo Kreizler/Sara Howard (Alienist TV)
  
  • Pining for ages until one of them finally makes a move
  
  
  • Someone makes a risky decision and proposes a threesome during one of the late nights working the first season case, and it pays off
  
  
  • Casefic/art! Either a full case or just a snippet of one. I love the idea of them working many cases together, although canon doesn’t exactly support that
  
  


• Libby Hatch/Sara Howard (Alienist TV)
  
  • Noncon or dubcon very welcome, as is something more consensual set prior to Sara finding out that Libby is the killer (and if you go with that, Sara’s feeling of betrayal could be very fun to explore)
  
  
  • Libby drugs Sara and has her way with her, or rapes her at gun- or knife-point
  
  
  • Libby kidnaps Sara as her new “baby” after the death of one of the actual infants. Please feel free to go full ageplay here!
  
  


• Sara Howard/Violet Hayward (The Alienist (TV))
  
  • Hatesex! Or Violet-on-Sara dubcon or noncon! I just think these two ends of the love triangle should connect somehow
  
  
  • Violet decides to see what John finds so enticing about Sara
  
  
  • Dub/noncon: Violet gets Sara very drunk at that party they were both at and has her way with her
  
  
  • Violet/Sara/John threesome also very welcome
  
  

Julie and the Phantoms

Fandom-specific DNW: mundane AUs/AUs where the ghosts are normal living people

Ships

• Caleb Covington/Luke Patterson
  
  • My prompts here lean dubcon/noncon rather than consensual, and if you’d prefer to go consensual, I’d like something that leans more “hatesex” than “fluffy and happy”
  
  
  • Honestly I just want some dirtybadwrong Caleb/Luke content
  
  
  • Caleb takes advantage of the binding he put on Luke
  
  
  • Alternatively, Caleb makes Luke an offer – do everything he says, and Alex and Reggie go free
  
  


• Caleb Covington/Willie (Julie and the Phantoms)
  
  • My prompts here lean dubcon/noncon rather than consensual, and if you’d prefer to go consensual, I’d like something that leans more “hatesex” than “fluffy and happy”
  
  
  • Honestly I just want some dirtybadwrong Caleb/Willie content
  
  
  • Willie’s job with Caleb involves other things (sex) as well as spying on potential acquisitions
  
  
  • Caleb punishes Willie for choosing Alex over him
  
  


• Julie Molina/Luke Patterson/Reggie Peters (Julie and the Phantoms)
  
• Give Julie ghost boyfriends!


• I’m really interested in the logistics of dating ghosts, since they usually can’t interact with the living world, and also that only Julie knows they exist so she’s pretty much required to keep the relationship a secret (although I am also very into her introducing her ghost boyfriends to the character/s of your choice)


• On a much shallower note – ghost sex


• Feel free to add Alex and/or Flynn to this ship! (I’d prefer no direct Alex/Julie action, but I totally ship the three boys and would love to see them adding Julie in)

Alex Mercer/Luke Patterson/Reggie Peters (Julie and The Phantoms)

• Seeing something set pre-death would be really fun here! (Feel free to include Bobby if you go this route)


• I’d also really love to see how death changes their relationship (either with an existing romantic and/or sexual relationship, or with their deaths inspiring one or more of them to confess their feelings)


• And again – ghost sex! Would love to see what new worlds being incorporeal opens up

Flynn/Julie Molina (Julie and The Phantoms)

• I just love these two and will enjoy any and all femslash about them


• I really love first time scenarios and/or seeing how relationships start for high school canons – the stakes often feel so high to the characters, especially if there’s any homophobia from their classmates in the mix


• How Flynn fits into Julie’s new relationship with her band, maybe Julie showing Flynn that she still cares about her even with her shiny new ghost friends

The Terror (TV)

Genital injury/removal is A-OK here for the male characters (please none for Silna though!). And feel free to lean into canon deaths and injuries, or get real weird with porn and/or torture and/or injuries. This fandom is very good at going absolutely wild with their fanworks and I love that about it! (Of course, things on the tamer side are also lovely!)

I have only seen the show, and I prefer show characterization where things diverge. But feel free to fill in backstories and draw from the plot of the novel.

General Prompts

• I am so in love with the idea of any or all of the characters coming across a portal through time and ending up in the modern day. I would love to see any of my requested ships dealing with modern technology and/or medicine, any of the m/m ships reacting to how much more acceptable gayness is in the 21st century, Hickey trying to con people and failing miserably since he doesn’t know anything about this century, characters being recognized as historical figures (the members of the expedition obviously, and then Silna I could see still being well-known among the modern Netsilik)
  


• Hurt/comfort, hurt/no-comfort, whump. Please feel free to dwell on the horrible things canon does to any of the characters in my requested ships, or add on more horrible things, and have the other ship member watch it happen/comfort them through it/help patch them up/etc


• Somebody lives or everybody lives AUs, especially exploring the aftermath of canon

Ships

• Cornelius Hickey/Harry D. S. Goodsir (Terror TV)
  
  • Anywhere along the spectrum from consensual to noncon is very welcome here!
  
  
  • For consensual, I enjoy seeing the contrast between their two moral codes, and perhaps Hickey trying to be a “good person” (or a genuinely good person) to get in good with Goodsir
  
  
  • Something set in the aftermath of the flogging when Hickey is being treated!
  
  
  • For noncon, I really love a Mutineer Trash Party where Hickey (and other mutineers if you like) do horrible things to Goodsir when he’s in their grasp
  
  



• Francis Crozier/Thomas Blanky (The Terror)
  
  • I will be happy with literally anything about them, their friendship is so great and I’d love to see them as lovers or fuckbuddies
  
  
  • Sneaking some time together while on the ship
  
  
  • Something about Blanky’s death through a shippy lens
    
  
  


• Francis Crozier/Thomas Jopson (The Terror)
  
  • I would especially love some dommy and/or top Jopson (in particular, his reaction to Hickey’s flogging made me think he might be a bit of a sadist)
  
  
  • Caretaking during Crozier quitting drinking. I know there’s a ton of fanworks out there already, but it’s a classic for a reason and I will love any iteration of this scenario
  
  
  • They-both-live AU where they have to figure out how to navigate their relationship without the power structure of the Navy (whether they stay in the Arctic or end up back in England)
    
  
  
• Harry D. S. Goodsir & Lady Silence | Silna (The Terror), Harry D. S. Goodsir/Lady Silence | Silna (The Terror)
  
  • I loved everything about Goodsir’s Inuktikuk dictionary and would love to see more of him learning Silna’s language (or teaching her a bit of English) in fic or art
  
  
  • AU where Silna ends up rescuing Goodsir from the mutineers’ camp (feel free to lean into the whump if you like, or make it more fluffy if that’s more your speed)
  
  
  • If you’re writing or drawing smut, I am especially into virgin or inexperienced or easily-flustered Goodsir
    
  
  
  • Something Tuunbaq-related leads to Silna and Goodsir being soulbonded (platonically or romantically)
  
  


• John Bridgens/Henry Peglar (The Terror)
  
• John Bridgens/Harry Peglar -
  
  • More sharing and discussing books! (Including cheesy 19th-century erotica if you want to get smutty)
  
  
  • Everyone-lives AU where they make it back to England and recover from scurvy and Arctic trauma together?
  
  
  • Alternatively, something terribly sad about their deaths
  
  
  • I would really love more porn about these two, especially kinky porn (for whatever kinks you feel moved to include). Someone on fail_fandomanon brought up crossdressing for them and that’s been eating my brain ever since, and I’d also love to see roleplay, but really, please feel free to just pick your favorite kink/s!